Maps are north-up: Garden Way runs along the bottom (south) edge, the driveway is on the west (left), the pool is behind the house to the north.
The two large backyard trees (one either side of the pool) are assumed removed, so Zones F and H can each carry 2-3 fruit trees.
Edible structure in every zone, ornamental at the street
The balanced option. A layered food forest: fruit trees anchor Zones A, D, F and H; deer-resistant berry shrubs form a protective collar in the front zones; herbaceous companions carry the bloom season from April to frost. Low-maintenance species only, with the owner's Zone A request honoured by putting an Asian pear on the street-facing (south) side of Zone A.
Maximum edibility and browse resistance, minimum pruning
The hardiest option. Every front-zone plant is either extremely deer resistant or protected by thorny or dense neighbours, and the edible payload is pushed into berries, currents, gooseberries and herbs rather than into tender fruit trees. Zone G becomes a perennial asparagus bed, and the backyard leans on pawpaw, plum and hazelnut with a heavier understory.
Fewer plants, more natives, near-zero maintenance
The lowest-maintenance option and the most wildlife-friendly. The palette is almost entirely native to the Cincinnati bioregion: serviceberry, American plum, pawpaw, hickory, hazelnut, nannyberry, arrowwood, spicebush and native perennials. Fruit trees are fewer, the front zones lean on large native shrubs, and Zone G becomes a low-mow native strip instead of a lawn.
Nothing here is ordered on your behalf. Nursery availability changes: Growing Value Nursery and the Cincinnati Permaculture Institute publish seasonal lists, and TreeYo sells by preorder and appointment.